Reviews by quinch

arrow_forwardMember Profile

all c64 only Amiga only

Displaying Reviews 1 - 4 out of 4

Login

Robocop3 (Gonna get you mad mix) - arranged by Mahoney

Review by quinch, 19/03/2006

I'm not sure what to make of this remix; on one hand, individually, the styles employed are good - very good, in fact. But together, they seem to be this… weird, amorphous mass that keeps tripping over itself as it stumbles toward the end. The execution is, as expected, excellent, but I cannot help but think that I would have liked the remix better if the singing, techno, guitar and other "parts" had been placed sequentially, rather than mixed together.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Great Giana Sisters Opening Theme - arranged by Mauve Park

Review by quinch, 13/12/2005

I'm afraid that the best thing that can be said about this remix is that's it's not inherently bad, and the experience of listening to it, if not the remix itself, is made so much worse by the feeling of disappointment it brings in just a few seconds after start.

It starts promising - immensely so, with a kind of "children at playground" background loop as the Giana Sisters theme opens with an eerie xylophone-ish instrument I could swear I've heard before in some horror movie or other, and it was a genuine surprise how well the theme fit to the creepy mood. "Okay, " I thought, "it's a bit too fast, but I can live with that. " And after a short while, it delivered… nothing. Nothing at all. About half a minute of eeriness, the melody shifts into the "generic remix" gear and stays there until the end. A little beat here, a little variation there, and we're done. There is one or two noteworthy points, likethe little twist around 1:23, but it's not nearly enough to pull it out of mediocrity; it's briefly promising, but it doesn't last.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Think Twice III (Now You're Not Here) - arranged by Perhaps-a-Doobie

Review by quinch, 15/10/2005

AAuuuggghhh make it stop awful singing please ears bleeding can't see to unplug the speakers funny lyrics will haunt me forever someone please please unplug the speakers have mercy how can a human voice warble so much the lyrics are so catchy oh FOR THE LOVE OF GHOD NO IT'S ON A LOOP…

{collapses in a twitching heap on the floor}
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

Rubicon (Main Titles) - arranged by Jan Morgenstern

Review by quinch, 15/10/2005

Let me start off by saying that Jan Morgenstern's "Rubicon" was a hair's breadth away from being deleted from my computer before I even finished listening to it. The beginning sounded rather unimpressive, opening up with an upbeat, but rather simplistic percussion rhythm, and the hit-and-run interjection of the melody didn't do wonders for my opinion either. And thus, as my finger was hovering over the "Delete" button, thinking this is another remix that was all cork and no pop, the song hit the minute-twenty mark, the main melody kicked in and the song took off like a cartoon coyote.

Once the song gets going, it *stays* going; it goes full out with the melody, background instruments and percussion, sometimes one yielding territory to the other two, such as the solo between 1:55 and 2:26 marks, but altough the intensity of the song varies from one part to another, it doesn't, at any point, fade. The final conclusion is that, with a masterful use of both the instruments and original melody, and enough flourish and improvisation to rise the original while staying true to it, this is a tone well worth listening until the end.

Just remember not to set Winamp to loop. Trust me on that one.
Technique
Artistic skill
Nostalgia factor
Overall rating

1